BREUER, ISAAC

BREUER, ISAAC (1883–1946), theoretician and leader of German Orthodoxy; son of Solomon Breuer and grandson of samson raphael hirsch . Born in Papa, Hungary, Breuer was brought as a child to Frankfurt, where he studied at his father's yeshiva and became a prominent figure in the local separatist Orthodox community (Austrittsgemeinde). He subsequently studied law, philosophy, and history at various universities and practiced as a lawyer in Frankfurt. He soon took a leading part in various communal organizations. He defended the secession of the Orthodox from the Jewish community in his Preussische Austrittsgesetzgebubg und das Judentum (1913). When agudat israel was founded in 1912, Breuer became one of its ideologists and most prominent spokesmen, though he developed a unique, non-conventional direction within ultra-Orthodox thought. He settled in Jerusalem (1936), practicing as a lawyer, and devoting himself to organizing Po'alei Agudat Israel, of which he became the president. His appeared on behalf of the Agudah before the Peel Commission (1937) and the Anglo-American Commission (March 1946). baruch kurzweil , his close student and spiritual heir, describes him as a charismatic teacher and a bohemian, artistic personality. Breuer, an heir to the work of S.R. Hirsch's doctrine of Torah im derekh ereẓ, redirected it with a national focus. In his early works – Messiasspuren (1918), Judenproblem (19224; also in a condensed English edition, 1947), Wegzeichen (a collection of articles, 1923; in expanded form in Hebrew, Ziyyunei Derekh, 1955) – he developed a notion of the Jewish people's national meta-historical Being as based on the juristic act of the covenant and the common duty to fulfill the divine law. Breuer's relationship to Zionism was ambivalent and dialectic. On the one hand, he regarded the movement as removing the Jewish people from the Torah by secularizing it and by locating it within historical temporality. In that respect he believed Zionism to be the worst enemy of Judaism. While Reform Judaism explicitly attacked the Torah, Zionism falsely pretended to assure the existence of the Jewish people, detaching it from its essential nature. On the other hand, Breuer shared the Zionist notion of the centrality of Ereẓ Israel and of the ideal of establishing a Jewish national home there, a state that should be a "state of Torah." In a series of works (Das juedische Nationalheim (1925; English translation, 1926); Elischa (1928), Der neue Kusari (1934), etc.) he developed this notion, viewing the British mandate over Ereẓ Israel and the Balfour declaration as the hand of divine providence, and called for an adjustment of the Hirschian "Torah im derekh ereẓ" doctrine as "Torah im derekh Ereẓ Israel." After settling in Ereẓ Isrel, Breuer began to write in Hebrew (Moriyyah, 1944; Nahali'el, 1951), while selected articles appeared posthumously in English (People of the Torah, 1956). In the earlier period he had written some – not very successful – novels (Ein Kampf um Gott, 1920; Falk Nefis Heimkehr, 1923), also as vehicles for his religious concepts. He defended his conception, in the philosophical terms of the 19th century that God's eternal truths were revealed in and to His "Torah people." When historical reality forced itself on his thought, he met its demand with struggle and reluctance. Breuer was also an heir of Hirsch in his religious-philosophic doctrine, combining a strong attachment to Kant with the freedom to move beyond the ontological and epistemological sphere of Kant's "thing-in-itself" (Ding als sich) as the object of faith and revelation. In line with Kant he defined rational scientific knowledge as limited and bound to its inner structures, which revelation overcomes and exceeds. Therefore miracles cannot be perceived by regular rational perception, bound to the laws of causality; only faith, perceiving the world as God's free creation, can transcend these boundaries and accept the idea of miracle. -BIBLIOGRAPHY: I Grunfeld, Three Generations (1958), index; S. Ehrmann, in: L. Jung (ed.), Guardians of Our Herritage (1958), 617–46; M. Morgenstern, From Frankfurt to Jerusalem: Isaac Breuer and the History of the Secession in Modern Jewish Orthodoxy (2002); R. Horwitz (ed.), Yiẓḥak BreuerIyyunim be-Mishnato (1988); A. Biemann, "Isaac Breuer – Zionist against His will?," in: Modern Judaism, 2:2 (2000), 129–46; D.H. Ellenson, "German Jewish Orthodoxy – Tradition in the Context of Culture," in: J. Wertheimer, The Uses of Tradition (1993), 5–22; R. Horwitz, "Exile and Redemption in the Thought of Isaac Breuer," in: Tradition, 26:2 (1992), 77–98; W.S. Wurzburger, "Breuer and Kant," in: Tradition 26:2 (1992), 71–76; E. Schweid, Toledot Filosofyat ha-Dat ha-Yehudit ba-Zeman he-Ḥadash, III, 2 (2005), 146–71; B. Kurzweil, Le-Nokhaḥ ha-Mevukhah ha-Ruḥanit shel Dorenu (1976), 117–30. (Yehoyada Amir (2nd ed.)

Encyclopedia Judaica. 1971.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Breuer, Isaac — (1883 1946)    He was the leader of Orthodox Jewry of Hungarian origin, the son of Solomon Breuer. He lived in Frankfurt am Main where he was active in Jewish organizations. When Agudat Israel was founded in 1912 he became one of its ideologists …   Dictionary of Jewish Biography

  • Isaac Breuer — (1883–1946) ( he. יצחק ברויאר) was a Jewish rabbi in the German Neo Orthodoxy movement of his maternal grandfather Samson Raphael Hirsch, and was the first president of Agudat Israel Workers. Biography Breuer was born in Pápa, Hungary to Salomon… …   Wikipedia

  • Isaac Breuer — (* 18. September 1883 in Pápa, Ungarn; † 10. Juli 1946 in Jerusalem, Israel) war ein deutschstämmiger Philosoph und ein bedeutender Vertreter des orthodoxen Judentums. Leben Breuer, ein Enkel von Samson Raphael Hirsch, wuchs in Frankfurt auf, wo… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Breuer — ist ein Familienname. Herkunft und Bedeutung Der Name gehört zu dem Bereich der Berufsnamen und bezeichnet den Brauer und Mälzer. Bekannte Namensträger Carolyn Breuer (* 1969), deutsche Sopran und Altsaxophonistin Christian Breuer… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • BREUER, MORDECHAI — (1921– ), religious Bible scholar. Breuer was born in Karlsruhe, Germany. His father, Samson Breuer, was a mathematician, and his uncle, Rabbi Isaac Breuer, was an Orthodox Jewish thinker who carried on the work of samson raphael hirsch .… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • BREUER, JOSEPH — (1882–1980), Orthodox rabbi; son of Solomon Breuer and grandson of samson raphael hirsch . Breuer was born in Papa, Hungary. In 1906, he became a lecturer at the yeshivah founded by his father in Frankfurt on the Main and became its head after… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Miles J. Breuer — Miles John Breuer (January 3, 1889 – October 14, 1945) was an American physician and science fiction writer. He was part of the first generation of writers to appear regularly in the pulp science fiction magazines, publishing his first story, The …   Wikipedia

  • Solomon Breuer — Shlomo Zalman (Solomon) Breuer (Pilisvörösvár, Hungary 1850 Frankfurt 1926) was a Rabbi, initially in Pápa, Hungary and from the early 1890s in Frankfurt as a successor of his father in law Samson Raphael Hirsch.cite book |author=Dovid Landesman …   Wikipedia

  • Mordechai Breuer (historian) — Mordechai Breuer (1917–2008) was a German Jewish Historian and writer. Background and Family Breuer was born to Isaac Breuer and his wife Jenny Breuer (nee Eisenmann) in 1917. He had four siblings: Yaakov; Ulla, Tzipora, and Simeon. The family… …   Wikipedia

  • CANPANTON (Campanton), ISAAC BEN JACOB — (1360–1463), Castilian rabbi. Canpanton was the head of a yeshivah in Zamora in western Spain, among whose students were isaac de leon , isaac aboab ii , Samuel b. Abraham Valensi, and shem tov ibn shem tov . He laid down methodological rules for …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.